Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine: Which One Should You Choose?

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Regarding hot tubs, homeowners often consider two popular options: Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine. Both alternatives offer advantages and disadvantages, so choosing the appropriate one might significantly impact how you want to use the tub. This post will examine the distinctions between saltwater and chlorine hot tubs, contrasting them regarding upkeep, cost, health benefits, and more. By the end of this article, you will clearly understand which type of hot tub best fits your needs and preferences.

Page Contents

Understanding Saltwater Hot Tubs

What is a Salt Water Hot Tub?

Saltwater hot tubs, or saltwater spas, utilize a salt chlorination system to keep the water clean and sanitized. Instead of adding chlorine directly to the water, these systems use a salt cell that converts the salt into chlorine through electrolysis. This chlorine is then used to disinfect the water, ensuring it remains safe and bacteria-free.

Benefits of Salt Water Hot Tubs

Gentler on the Skin: Saltwater hot tubs typically have lower chlorine levels than chlorine-based hot tubs, making them more delicate on the skin and eyes.
Softer Water: The salt content in salt water hot tubs can contribute to softer-feeling water, providing a more pleasant soaking experience.
Reduced Chlorine Odor: One common complaint of chlorine-based hot tubs is the strong odor. Saltwater hot tubs tend to have a milder and less noticeable chlorine smell.
Lower Maintenance: Saltwater systems often require less maintenance than traditional chlorine-based systems. The salt cell only needs periodic cleaning; you must not add chlorine manually.

Drawbacks of Salt Water Hot Tubs

Initial Cost: Salt water hot tubs can be more expensive due to the additional equipment required for the salt chlorination system.
Salt Corrosion: The salt content in the water can corrode specific metal components of the hot tub over time. Regular maintenance and monitoring are required to prevent any issues.
Electricity Consumption: Saltwater systems rely on electrolysis, which consumes electricity. This can lead to slightly higher energy costs compared to traditional chlorine-based methods.

Exploring Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

What is a Chlorine-Based Hot Tub?

Chlorine-based hot tubs, or traditional hot tubs, rely on adding chlorine or other chemical sanitizers directly to the water to maintain proper sanitation levels. Chlorine kills bacteria, algae, and other contaminants, ensuring the hot tub water remains safe and clean.

Benefits of Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

Cost-Effective: Chlorine-based hot tubs are generally more affordable upfront than salt water hot tubs.
Wide Availability: Chlorine-based sanitizers and chemicals are readily available in the market, making it easier to maintain the hot tub.
Effective Sanitization: Chlorine is a powerful disinfectant that kills bacteria and other contaminants in the water.
Flexibility in Chlorine Levels: With a chlorine-based hot tub, you have more control over the chlorine levels in the water, allowing you to adjust it based on your preferences.

Drawbacks of Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

Harsher on the Skin: For some people, increased chlorine levels in the water might irritate their eyes and skin.
Chlorine Odor: Chlorine-based hot tubs often have a distinct and robust chlorine odor, which can be off-putting for some users.
Regular Monitoring and Maintenance: Chlorine levels must be adjusted to ensure proper sanitation. Additionally, other chemicals may be required to balance pH levels and prevent algae growth.

Hot tubs with salt water: Pros and Cons

Pros of Salt Water Hot Tubs

Gentler on the Skin: The lower chlorine levels in saltwater hot tubs make them more suitable for individuals with sensitive skin.
Softer Water: Salt in the water can create a more peaceful and soothing soaking experience.
Reduced Chlorine Odor: Salt water hot tubs tend to have a milder chlorine smell, making the experience more pleasant.
Lower Maintenance: Saltwater systems generally require less maintenance than chlorine-based systems, reducing the hassle and effort involved.

Cons of Salt Water Hot Tubs

Higher Initial Cost: Saltwater hot tubs typically have a higher initial cost due to the additional equipment needed for the salt chlorination system.
Salt Corrosion: The salt content in the water can potentially corrode specific metal components of the hot tub, requiring regular monitoring and maintenance.
Electricity Consumption: The electrolysis process in saltwater systems consumes electricity, resulting in slightly higher energy costs.

Pros and Cons of Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

Pros of Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

Cost-Effective: Chlorine-based hot tubs are generally more affordable upfront, making them a budget-friendly option.
Wide Availability: Chlorine-based sanitizers and chemicals are widely available, making it easier to maintain the hot tub.
Effective Sanitization: Chlorine is a powerful disinfectant that kills bacteria and contaminants, ensuring clean water.
Flexibility in Chlorine Levels: With a chlorine-based hot tub, you have more control over the chlorine levels, allowing customization.

Cons of Chlorine-Based Hot Tubs

Harsher on the Skin: Higher chlorine levels may cause skin and eye irritation, particularly for sensitized individuals.
Chlorine Odor: Chlorine-based hot tubs often have a noticeable chlorine smell, which can be unpleasant for some users.
Regular Monitoring and Maintenance: Chlorine levels must be regularly monitored and adjusted, and additional chemicals may be required for proper maintenance.

Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine: Comparison

Now that we have explored the benefits and drawbacks of both saltwater hot tubs and chlorine hot tubs, let’s compare them side by side to help you make an informed decision:

Feature	Salt Water Hot Tub	Chlorine Hot Tub
Water Sanitization	The salt cell converts salt into chlorine for natural sanitization.	Chlorine-based chemicals used for sanitization
Skin Sensitivity	Gentler on the skin	Some individuals may experience skin irritation
Maintenance	Less manual maintenance required	Regular monitoring and addition of chemicals
Initial Cost	Higher upfront cost	Lower upfront cost
Water Corrosion	Potential corrosion if not properly balanced and maintained	Lower risk of corrosion
Water Sensation	Softer water	Potential for stronger chemical odor
Compatibility	It may not be compatible with all hot tub materials.	Compatible with various hot tub materials
Chemical Handling	Limited handling of salt required	Regular handling of chlorine chemicals
Water Odor and Taste	It may not be compatible with all hot tub materials	Potential for more pungent chemical odor

Consider these factors based on your preferences, budget, and hot tub requirements to determine whether a saltwater or chlorine hot tub is the right choice.

Comparing Maintenance Requirements Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine

Maintaining a hot tub requires regular care and attention, whether a saltwater hot tub or a chlorine-based hot tub. However, the two options have some differences in their maintenance requirements.

Maintenance and Care for Salt Water Hot Tubs

Your saltwater hot tub will operate best and last the longest with proper maintenance and upkeep. Here are some critical maintenance tasks to keep in mind:

Water Balance: Regularly test the pH, alkalinity, and calcium hardness levels. Adjust them to maintain a balanced environment for the salt cell and equipment.
Salt Cell Cleaning: Mineral buildup can occur on the salt cell over time. Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to clean the cell periodically to maintain effectiveness.
Salt Level Monitoring: Check the salt level in the water regularly. Add salt as needed to keep the recommended concentration for proper chlorine generation.
Water Filtration: Clean or replace the hot tub filters according to the manufacturer’s guidelines. This helps ensure efficient water circulation and filtration.
Water Shocking: Periodically shock the water with a non-chlorine shock oxidizer to eliminate contaminants and maintain water clarity.

Maintenance and Care for Chlorine Hot Tubs

If you decide to go with a chlorine hot tub, here are some maintenance tips to keep your hot tub in top condition:

Water Testing: Regularly test the water for pH, sanitizer levels, and total alkalinity. Adjust the chemical levels accordingly to maintain a safe and clean hot tub environment.
Chlorine Addition: Follow the manufacturer’s instructions to add chlorine-based chemicals to the hot tub. Monitor the sanitizer levels and adjust the chlorine dosage as needed.
Filter Maintenance: Regularly clean or replace hot tub filters to ensure optimal filtration and water quality. Dirty filters can hinder the effectiveness of the chlorine sanitizer.
Shock Treatment: Periodically shock the hot tub water using a chlorine shock product to eliminate bacteria, algae, and other contaminants. This helps maintain water clarity and sanitation.
Drain and Refilling: It’s essential to drain and refill the hot tub water every few months to maintain water quality and remove accumulated contaminants. Follow the manufacturer’s guidelines for the recommended frequency of water replacement.

Cost Analysis: Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine

When considering the cost of owning a hot tub, it’s essential to evaluate the upfront and ongoing maintenance costs. Here’s a breakdown of the cost factors for saltwater hot tubs and chlorine hot tubs:

Initial Cost: Saltwater hot tubs generally have a higher initial cost due to the saltwater system and related equipment. Chlorine hot tubs tend to be more affordable in terms of upfront expenses.
Maintenance Cost: Saltwater hot tubs have lower ongoing maintenance costs than chlorine hot tubs. While chlorine-based chemicals must be regularly purchased for chlorine hot tubs, saltwater hot tubs require salt replenishment, which is typically less expensive.
Equipment Maintenance: Both types of hot tubs require equipment maintenance, such as cleaning the filters and maintaining the hot tub components. The equipment maintenance cost can vary depending on the hot tub model and features.
Water and Energy Consumption: Hot tubs require water and energy to operate regardless of the type. The water and energy consumption cost will depend on usage frequency, local utility rates, and the hot tub’s energy efficiency.

When deciding between a chlorine hot tub and a saltwater hot tub, you must consider your budget and future expenses. It’s also worth noting that while saltwater hot tubs may have a higher upfront cost, the savings in maintenance expenses over time can offset the initial investment.

Choosing the Right for You Salt Water Hot Tubs or Chlorine

Choosing between a saltwater hot tub and a chlorine hot tub ultimately depends on your preferences, needs, and priorities. Here are some factors to consider when making your decision:

Maintenance Preference: A saltwater hot tub may be suitable if you prefer a hot tub with lower maintenance requirements and automated sanitization. However, enjoy more hands-on maintenance and control over chlorine levels. A chlorine hot tub might be a better fit.
Budget: Evaluate your budget and consider the initial cost, ongoing maintenance expenses, and potential savings over time. Determine what you’re comfortable spending on a hot tub and factor in the necessary chemicals or salt price.
Skin Sensitivity: If you have sensitive skin or are prone to skin irritations, a saltwater hot tub may be a better option due to its lower chlorine concentration. However, testing the water and ensuring it doesn’t cause adverse reactions is essential.
Water Sensation: Consider whether you prefer the softer water sensation often associated with salt water hot tubs or if you don’t mind the typical chlorine scent and taste that can be present in chlorine hot tubs.
Compatibility: If you already own a hot tub or have a specific hot tub material in mind, check its compatibility with saltwater systems or chlorine-based sanitizers. Ensure that the hot tub you choose is designed to work with your preferred sanitization method.
Expert Advice: Consult with hot tub professionals, dealers, or experts who can provide insights about your situation.

To make a wise choice, consider these factors and conduct comprehensive research to find the hot tub that fits your lifestyle and needs.

Common Myths About Salt Water Hot Tubs vs. Chlorine

Several misconceptions and myths surround saltwater hot tubs and chlorine hot tubs. Let’s debunk some of the common myths:

Myth: Saltwater hot tubs are completely chlorine-free.
Fact: While saltwater hot tubs generate chlorine through electrolysis, they still contain chlorine. The difference lies in the method of chlorine generation, which is through the conversion of salt rather than directly adding chlorine-based chemicals.
Myth: Saltwater hot tubs are maintenance-free.
Fact: While salt water hot tubs require less manual chlorination, they still require regular maintenance, including monitoring salt levels, cleaning the salt cell, and balancing water chemistry.
Myth: Chlorine hot tubs are harmful to the skin and eyes.
Fact: When used correctly and with appropriate water balance, chlorine hot tubs are generally safe for the skin and eyes. Skin and eye irritations are often the result of improper water chemistry rather than the chlorine itself.
Myth: Saltwater hot tubs taste like seawater.
Fact: Saltwater hot tubs are not excessively salty. The salt concentration is usually around 3,000 to 5,000 parts per million (ppm), much lower than seawater’s salinity.
Myth: Saltwater hot tubs eliminate the need for any additional chemicals.
Fact: While saltwater hot tubs generate chlorine for sanitization, different chemicals, such as pH adjusters and alkalinity increasers, may still be required to maintain proper water balance.

It’s important to separate fact from fiction when considering saltwater and chlorine hot tubs. Always rely on reliable sources and consult with professionals to make informed decisions.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are saltwater hot tubs better for your skin?

Saltwater hot tubs are generally considered gentler on the skin due to lower chlorine levels, which can reduce skin irritation and dryness.

Does a saltwater hot tub feel like swimming in the ocean?

While saltwater hot tubs have a salt content, the concentration is much lower than in the sea. The water may feel softer and smoother, but it won’t replicate the experience of swimming in the ocean.

Do saltwater hot tubs require less maintenance than chlorine-based hot tubs?

Saltwater hot tubs often require less maintenance compared to chlorine-based systems. However, regular salt level monitoring and cleaning of the salt cell are necessary.

Can I convert my chlorine-based hot tub to a saltwater system?

Sometimes, converting a chlorine-based hot tub to a saltwater system is possible. However, it may require modifications and professional assistance.

Do chlorine-based hot tubs have a strong chlorine smell?

Yes, chlorine-based hot tubs can have a distinct chlorine odor. However, proper maintenance and water balancing can help minimize the smell.

Is it safe to soak in a saltwater hot tub if I have allergies?

Suppose you have known allergies to specific minerals or substances found in salt water. Consulting with a healthcare professional before using a saltwater hot tub is recommended.

Are saltwater hot tubs more eco-friendly than chlorine-based hot tubs?

Saltwater hot tubs may have some environmental advantages, such as reduced chemical disposal. However, it’s essential to consider the overall environmental impact and water consumption.

Do chlorine-based hot tubs require more water than saltwater hot tubs?

Chlorine-based hot tubs typically require more water circulation for proper sanitation, leading to increased water consumption than saltwater hot tubs.

Can I still use spa chemicals in a saltwater hot tub?

Yes, you can still use spa chemicals in a saltwater hot tub. However, chemical usage may be reduced compared to chlorine-based systems.

Conclusion

Choosing between a saltwater hot tub and a chlorine-based hot tub is a decision that depends on your preferences, budget, and maintenance capabilities. Saltwater hot tubs offer gentler water, reduced chlorine odor, and lower maintenance requirements. On the other hand, chlorine-based hot tubs are more cost-effective upfront and provide flexibility in chlorine levels. Consider skin sensitivities, maintenance preferences, environmental impact, and cost when choosing. Ultimately, select the most enjoyable and comfortable hot tub experience option. Regularly monitor water chemistry, maintain proper sanitation, and follow safety guidelines for a pleasurable, relaxing, and desirable tub experience.

Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc, or its affiliates.